Doubt because blood transfusion infects third liver Inform 17 years later the hospital can reach in incubation period 20

Doubt because blood transfusion infects third liver Inform 17 years later the hospital can reach in incubation period 20
Judicial expertise : Blood transfusion and the third liver have river district the People's Hospital of summer of causalities: Checked the requirement without third liver in blood transfusion before 1993
November 10, blood person who pollute district open a court session by court in summer such as river, this district dark the intersection of dragon and the intersection of spring and pieces of the intersection of jade and plum, resident of street, indict the intersection of river and summer district the People's Hospital, think oneself was infected with third liver then caused liver cirrhosis during blood transfusion of this institute 17 years agoed, claim 24 from hospital Wan Yuan.
A skillful one that it has goes through similar to be a people with YuMei Zhang. Several third liver patient whom the reporter saw, had all had experience of transfusing blood in this hospital many years ago, and third liver can for 20 years.
Did blood transfusion infect third liver 17 years ago?
In the morning of yesterday, there were very few pedestrians in the street of spring of dark dragon of summer of river, seemed extremely lonely. Because the wind is too heavy, a small grocery managed of Zhang YuMei has only opened half a door. She is making up the goods furnished in the counter, and the wife is looking after the grandson sleeping soundly in the table.
In May of this year, the 52 -year-old Zhang Yu's plum feels the body goes from bad to worse, " L Without strength, dizzy, feel nervous in the heart, sometimes it is very difficult to get up " . Under the insistance of husband and son, Zhang YuMei goes to province the People's Hospital to check, " L Having nearly look through all departments are OK, we check the blood under the doctor's suggestion. " L The inspection result reveals, a jade plum is suffered from " R Third liver liver cirrhosis " .
This result lets whole family Mei of a piece of jade nearly all indebted to, its husband Ma XianJun can not understand after repeated thinking especially, through looking for the materials in many ways, inquire a doctor draws the conclusion: " Family have the intersection of liver and medical history, son and I have, can only infect of blood transfusion. "
This let whole family remember landslide accident together 17 years ago, Zhang YuMei's right leg dropped 7 grades woundedly and incompletely. Just because of that accident, she gets in river summer district the People's Hospital treats, and blood transfusion. Ma XianJun remembers : " It was a blood donor phoning to send for in the hospital at that time, wanted not to think of going wrong at all. "
Subsequently, Ma XianJun has found every pile and shown the neat size document, some writing has been already fuzzy. At the 4 document, record wife in will it be April - July 1992 due to wound in the intersection of Wuchang and hospital, people of county, among them During the treatment period, detailed time, measuring and expenses for blood transfusion,etc..
The reporter notices, these 4 " L Fetch blood and blood plasma and count bills " R Divide two specification, two blood of 900ml come from the intersection of Wuhan and the intersection of city center and blood station together among them, the price adds up to 360 yuan; Another two>Reveal, one is that the blood of 900ml comes from " L Sun FaXiang " R Blood donor,total price 385 yuans, differ by time for 14 day, it and enclose " L Stay in the blood donating team of county people's hospital of Wuchang and take the place of the fee of certificate " R Specialized seal.
Judicial expertise : There is causality
Will it be June this year, XianJun Ma the intersection of blood transfusion and treatment result in, it suffers from third liver to be from at time when district the People's Hospital is in hospital in river summer with wife, the book faces the hospital to lodge claims.
The hospital provides and replies in writing quickly: Evidence that patient offer enough to prove, suffer from hepatitis C, be caused during blood transfusion of this institute, demand to refuse to approve of compensation, " L If the patient objects to reply of the our academy, can complain to the health authorities of higher level; Apply for the malpractice to appraise; Bring a suit before people's court directly . "
Persistent Ma XianJun is taking the wife to go to the judicial expertise department to appraise subsequently. On October 13, the judicial testimonial that the science and technology consultative centre of Wuhan provides determines the opinion is: Here a jade plum of surveyor" L The county people's hospital of Wuchang " Blood transfusion instead of suffering from now hepatitis Cs chronic causality.
The day before yesterday, Zhang YuMei's Israel " L In hospital result in blood transfusion it suffer from third liver is from " R The case of district the People's Hospital opens a court session to indict the river in summer.
" The blood donor is sent for by the hospital, the hospital must be responsible for meeting an accident. " Though the court has not pronounced yet at present, seem quite sure that Ma XianJun wins a lawsuit to the lawsuit.
Hospital : Checked the requirement without third liver in blood transfusion before 1993
River summer the intersection of district and department, medical matters of the People's Hospital, one Peng whether section chief tell reporter whether hepatitis C by third the intersection of liver and virus Cause, through blood transfusion or the intersection of blood and products and blood dialyse and plasma pheresis return blood transfusion ball, renal transplantation, the intersection of intravenous injection and drugs, spread through sex intercourse, mother-to-baby transmission,etc. to infect, cause. Not third liver of blood transfusion only propagates the route, it is 26 weeks that it is third liver incubation period is the longest and blood transfusion causes, if Zhang YuMei can prove that infect third liver 26 weeks later, can infer that there are positive connections with the blood transfusion of hospital. However, it is many persons of expert tell reporter whether be entered behind human body third liver virus,will incubation period for some time, make third without any symptom, patient of liver, third liver 2 weeks - 26 weeks in incubation period generally, it can be up to 20 years that it is the longest, most third liver patients became chronic third liver carrier like this, until liver cirrhosis.
In addition, section chief Peng also raises questions, the blood that Zhang YuMei failed has two sources, first, the hospital, second, blood station, " L Can't verify now which kind of blood goes wrong. Not in order to talk about definitely, why is the question of the hospital? "
What is worth mentioning is, time of Zhang YuMei's blood transfusion was in 1992. Ministry of Public Health is in 1993 Release on annual February 17>Article 5 has increased the index that blood donor's blood checks third liver antibody, and express regulations and carry out from July 1, 1993. That is to say, are limited to the technological condition at that time before this, check to the blood of blood donors and the receptor in the index, not including the liver antibody test, third liver is not regarded as blood transfusion and must check the project.
Then, become blood transfusion infect third borderline of liver a bit 1993, third liver that catch before this who come, responsible for on earth?
" Make the hospital responsible for, the comparative wrong that I think. " Section chief Peng says, before 1993, they accorded with the standard of Chinese Health Ministry to the test before blood transfusion, legally, the hospital does not have fault, do not need to take on the responsibility naturally.
Case
Blood transfusion infects third liver,
The patient indicts the hospital and wins a lawsuit
In river summer, that have the same experience is not a person with Zhang YuMei.
One community 37 -year-old Chen Yin in the paper workshop of this district lives, an accident in November of 2005 is sprained and felt by her " L Very lucky " ,If not this accident, third liver of hers will be found by later period.
" Sprain the waist go on the belly Ultrasonography B, check, find in surprise that there is liver cirrhosis, it is liver cirrhosis that third liver initiated to make a definite diagnosis of later. " Husband of Yin Chen it scribbles flat to be might cause third factor of liver get rid of one by one, he has remembered as far back as June of 1994, the wife was after district the People's Hospital carried on the caesarean birth operation in river summer
|